MAC Chestnut Lip Pencil
On the hunt for a MAC Chestnut Lip Pencil dupe that won’t break the bank?
You’re in luck. MAC’s iconic Chestnut Lip Pencil, beloved for its rich, warm brown hue, is a must-have for many but comes with a price tag that might not fit every budget. The good news is, the market is flooded with alternatives that offer similar color payoff and quality at a more wallet-friendly price.
Well, we’ll be going over:
- What should you look for in a dupe to ensure it lives up to the iconic status of MAC’s Chestnut Lip Pencil?
- How do these budget-friendly alternatives stack up in terms of pigmentation, texture, and longevity?
- Which dupes stand out as the top contenders for replicating the look and feel of the original Chestnut Lip Pencil?
Let’s dive in.

Best MAC Chestnut Lip Pencil Dupes
If you’re a fan of MAC’s Chestnut lip pencil but don’t want to spend the money on the original, you’re in luck. There are plenty of affordable dupes available that offer the same rich, warm brown shade without breaking the bank.
In this roundup, we’ve compiled a list of the best MAC Chestnut lip pencil dupes that are just as good as the real thing. Whether you’re looking for a matte or glossy finish, we’ve got you covered. So, without further ado, let’s dive into the list.
MAC Lip Pencil – CHESTNUT

If you’re looking for a long-lasting lip liner that is smudge-free and easy to apply, then MAC Lip Pencil in Chestnut is definitely worth considering.
Pros
- This lip pencil is formulated for a soft, creamy application that glides on smoothly, making it easy to define and shape your lips.
- It provides long-lasting definition of the lips, so you don’t have to worry about touch-ups throughout the day.
- The Chestnut shade is a versatile color that works well with a variety of lipstick shades and skin tones.
Cons
- The price point may be a bit high for some users.
- The pencil tip may break easily if not handled with care.
- Some users may find the pencil to be too dry or difficult to apply.
If you’re looking for a more affordable alternative to MAC Lip Pencil in Chestnut, there are several great dupes available on the market. One of the best options is the NYX Slim Lip Pencil in Nutmeg. This lip pencil provides a similar color and texture to the MAC Lip Pencil, but at a fraction of the cost.
Another great dupe is the Milani Color Statement Lip Liner in Spice. This lip pencil is highly pigmented and provides a smooth, creamy application that lasts all day. The Spice shade is a close match to the Chestnut shade of the MAC Lip Pencil.
If you’re on a tight budget, the Wet n Wild Perfect Pout Gel Lip Liner in Bare to Comment is a great option. This lip liner provides a smooth, creamy application that lasts for hours, and the Bare to Comment shade is a close match to the Chestnut shade of the MAC Lip Pencil.
Overall, if you’re looking for a high-quality lip pencil that provides long-lasting definition and a versatile color, then MAC Lip Pencil in Chestnut is definitely worth considering. However, if you’re looking for a more affordable alternative, there are several great dupes available on the market that provide a similar color and texture at a fraction of the cost.
MAC Lip Pencil Chestnut

If you’re looking for an affordable alternative to the MAC Lip Pencil Chestnut, we’ve got you covered. Here are the pros and cons of some of the best MAC Chestnut lip pencil dupes out there.
Pros
- Affordable: Save money without sacrificing quality.
- Long-lasting: You won’t have to constantly reapply throughout the day.
- Versatile: These dupes match a wide range of skin tones and lip colors.
Cons
- Limited availability: Some dupes may be harder to find than others.
- Slightly different texture: The texture may not be exactly the same as the original MAC lip pencil.
- May smudge: Some dupes may smudge more easily than the MAC lip pencil.
If you’re on a budget but still want a high-quality lip pencil, the MAC Lip Pencil Chestnut dupes are a great option. These affordable alternatives offer a long-lasting formula that matches a wide range of skin tones and lip colors. However, keep in mind that some dupes may be harder to find and may have a slightly different texture than the original MAC lip pencil. Additionally, some dupes may smudge more easily than the MAC lip pencil, so be sure to choose a product that works well for you.
Wet n Wild Lip Liner Pencil Color Icon Lip Color Makeup

If you’re looking for an affordable lip liner that delivers, Wet n Wild Lip Liner Pencil Color Icon Lip Color Makeup, Dark Brown Chestnut is a great option.
Pros
- This rich, creamy formula glides on silky-smooth and makes sure your lip color doesn’t bleed so you’ll always have a well-defined pout.
- Makeup artists love to use this as a lipstick, applying it all over the lips.
- They last longer and make sure you’re not rocking that early 90s two-toned lip!
Cons
- The color may not be an exact match for everyone’s skin tone.
- It may be a bit drying for some people’s lips.
- It may not be as long-lasting as some other high-end lip liners.
Wet n Wild Lip Liner Pencil Color Icon Lip Color Makeup, Dark Brown Chestnut has a rich, creamy formula that glides on smoothly, ensuring that your lip color stays put and doesn’t bleed. Makeup artists love to use this as a lipstick, applying it all over the lips. The liner lasts longer and ensures that you’re not sporting an early 90s two-toned lip. However, the color may not be an exact match for everyone’s skin tone, and it may be a bit drying for some people’s lips. Additionally, it may not be as long-lasting as some other high-end lip liners. Overall, if you’re looking for an affordable option that delivers, this is a great choice.
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil

If you’re looking for a budget-friendly lip liner that delivers long-lasting results, NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil is a great option to consider.
Pros
- Natural shades: This lip liner comes in a variety of natural shades, including Espresso 820, which is a beautiful brown color that complements most skin tones.
- Long-wearing formula: The buttery soft, long-wearing lip pencil formula goes on easily and resists bleeding, so you can enjoy a perfect pout all day long.
- Cruelty-free: NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP is a cruelty-free brand that doesn’t test any of its products on animals, so you can feel good about your purchase.
Cons
- Matte finish: If you prefer a lip liner that glides and feels moisturizing, this may not be the best option for you as it has a matte finish.
- May be too hard: Some users report that the pencil is too hard to use and too thick, making it difficult to apply.
- Slightly lighter: A few users have reported that the batch they received was slightly lighter and more red than normal.
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil is a budget-friendly, long-lasting lip liner that goes on easily and resists bleeding. Its natural shades and cruelty-free formula make it a great option for those who want to look good and feel good about their purchase.
The buttery soft, long-wearing formula glides on easily, but some users may find it too hard to apply. Additionally, if you prefer a lip liner with a moisturizing finish, this may not be the best option for you. However, if you’re looking for a budget-friendly lip liner that delivers natural shades and long-lasting results, NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Lip Pencil is definitely worth considering.
Evpct 3Pcs Chestnut Nude Brown Lip Liner and Lipstick Set Kit

If you’re looking for a versatile lip product that combines a lip liner and lipstick, the Evpct 3Pcs Chestnut Nude Brown Lip Liner and Lipstick Set Kit for Women might be worth considering.
Pros
- The dual-ended design allows you to use both lipstick and lip liner on both ends, making it easy to draw a delicate lip line before applying lipstick.
- The lipstick is long-lasting and waterproof, with a matte velvet finish that’s highly pigmented and easy to apply.
- The set comes with six popular colors, making it a great gift option for Valentine’s Day, birthdays, Mother’s Day, and other occasions.
Cons
- Some customers reported that the product doesn’t last as long as advertised and lacks moisture.
- The pigment isn’t as vibrant as some customers expected.
- One of the nude shades might be old and dried out, according to some customers.
Overall, the Evpct 3Pcs Chestnut Nude Brown Lip Liner and Lipstick Set Kit for Women is a convenient and beautiful lip makeup set that’s suitable for all seasons and occasions. The dual-ended design makes it easy to apply, and the long-lasting, waterproof formula ensures that your lips look perfect all day long. However, some customers reported issues with the product’s longevity and moisture content, so it might not be the best option for everyone.
Buying Guide
When searching for a MAC Chestnut Lip Pencil dupe, there are a few factors to consider to ensure you choose the best product for your needs. Here are some features to look for when selecting a dupe:
Color
The most important feature to consider when looking for a MAC Chestnut Lip Pencil dupe is the color. Look for a product that matches the same shade as the original MAC Chestnut Lip Pencil. A dupe that is too light or too dark will not give you the same look as the original.
Texture
The texture of the dupe is also important to consider. Look for a product that has a smooth and creamy texture, which will make it easy to apply and blend. A dupe that is too dry or too sticky may not give you the same results as the original.
Longevity
Another factor to consider when choosing a MAC Chestnut Lip Pencil dupe is its longevity. Look for a product that has a long-lasting formula, which will ensure that your lip color stays put for hours. A dupe that fades quickly or smudges easily will not give you the same long-lasting results as the original.
Price
Price is also an important factor to consider when choosing a MAC Chestnut Lip Pencil dupe. Look for a product that is affordable and within your budget. A dupe that is too expensive may not be worth the investment, especially if you can find a more affordable alternative that gives you the same results.
By considering these factors, you can choose the best MAC Chestnut Lip Pencil dupe for your needs. Take your time to research and compare different products to find the one that meets your expectations and fits within your budget.