We bet you’d agree – not everyone is blessed with naturally bushy eyebrows like Cara Delevingne!
While most people prefer eyebrow extensions for thickening eyebrows, we’d suggest stacking your makeup kit with eyebrow makeup products. Besides shaping unruly brows, an eyebrow pencil will frame your face while complementing your features.
Of all the makeup products, eyebrow pencils are perfect for filling in arches, shaping brows, and adding volume.
With tons of options on the market, finding the best organic eyebrow pencil is in no way an easy task. But don’t worry, for we’ve gone into the nitty-gritty of eyebrow pencils and shortlisted the seven top-notch options to help you find the perfect one for amping your makeup game.
So, let’s dive right in!
7 Best Organic Eyebrow Pencils For A Full And Natural Look
1. PYT Defining Brow Goals Pencil
Kickstarting our list is this brow pencil by PYT that is perfect for defining, filling, and shaping your eyebrows. Thanks to its unique oval tip, it fills sparse areas and thickens your brows with precision. At the same time, there’s a spoolie brush attached to the other end of the pencil, which can be used to buff the eyebrows for a seamless finish. Plus, it comes with a sharpener, so you won’t have to purchase it separately.
Infused with nourishing Vitamin E , this eyebrow pencil protects the brow hairs from moisture and UV-induced radical damage. What’s more, it’s available in blonde, taupe, warm brown, chocolate, and warm black, so you’re free to choose the one that matches your brow color. We’d also like to mention that the formula is free from fragrance, alcohol, and soy.
Though one of the best eyebrow pencils, it is prone to smudging, so it isn’t suitable for oily skin.
With its retractable tip and spoolie brush, it is easy to use, which makes it perfect for beginners. Unlike other eyebrow pencils, it blends well, ensuring the perfect finish, which is the icing on the cake.
2. Ere Perez Almond Eyebrow Pencil
Looking for a natural eyebrow pencil that will draw smooth tiny hairs for a well-defined look without making it look like a tattoo? If yes, then the Ere Perez Almond Eyebrow Pencil is excellent for filling in and shaping brows. With sweet almond oil  as the star ingredient, it strengthens your hair and nourishes the skin around the brows. Adding to that is candelilla (euphorbia cerifera) wax  that nourishes and hydrates the skin.
It’s also packed with hydrogenated vegetable (olus) oil  to form a barrier over the skin and prevent moisture loss. This eyebrow pencil comes in a light neutral-brown gray shade, so it’s perfect for all skin tones. Jam-packed with emollients, waxes, and other ingredients, it glides on the brows easily, so you won’t face difficulties in drawing hair-like strokes. As a bonus, it comes with a brush that ensures even application and creates natural-looking brows.
The only downside is that it isn’t as long-lasting as others in its price range.
Available in a universal shade, this eyebrow pencil is a perfect fit for various skin tones and hair shades. While the tip glides easily over the brows to fill the gaps, the brush tames fly-away hairs, providing a smooth finish.
3. Westman Atelier Bonne Brow Defining Pencil
This cult-favorite eyebrow pencil is a must-have for every makeup junkie who likes to give their eyebrows a fluffier yet natural look. The Westman Atelier retractable pencil boasts of an angled tip that glides smoothly on the brows, while the spoolie comes in handy for blending the color for a more natural “Bonne Brow” look. What’s more, it’s made with 100% naturally-derived pigments, which makes it safe for all skin types.
One such ingredient found in the formula is hydrogenated castor oil  which softens and moisturizes the skin around the brows, keeping them healthy. That’s not all; this brow pencil is available in four different colors (clay, slate, bark, and stone), so you’ll find the right shade without any difficulty. It also offers excellent coverage, which is why it’s a go-to pick for makeup artists.
It comes with an expensive price tag, so you’ll have to shell out some extra bucks.
Those who prefer going for eyebrow pencils that are one shade lighter than their natural hair color will find the Westman Atelier pencil worth adding to their makeup kit. We also appreciate the detachable spoolie that you can use as an eraser to soften or blend the strokes.
4. Plume Science Nourish & Define Brow Pencil
On the hunt for an eyebrow pencil that will let you swim in the sea without fading? Then this luxurious brow pencil from the house of Plume Science Nourish & Define is worth every cent. Enriched with the goodness of shea butter , it keeps the hair follicles moisturized and promotes their growth. Furthermore, the blend includes Olea europaea fruit oil , which is rich in vitamins, fatty acids, and antioxidants, so it will nourish dry skin.
Other than that, the formula is packed with fruit extracts, oils, wax, and other naturally sourced ingredients that add to its potency. Unlike other brow pencils, it’s refillable, which means you can save a few bucks by buying the refill pack. That’s not all; this eyebrow pencil is available in six shades, namely ebony, taupe, medium brown, auburn, blonde, and chocolate brown.
Beginners may find it challenging to use because the pigment is slightly waxy.
This product steals the show with its gentle yet effective formula that defines the brows but also promotes the growth of hair follicles. And this nourishing blend won’t smudge, so it’s perfect for long wear.
5. Kimiko Super Fine Eyebrow Pencil Automatique
Tired of searching brands that offer eyebrow pencils for blonde and dark blonde brows? Then Kimiko Super Fine Eyebrow Pencil Automatique is the perfect fit for accentuating your brow hairs a fuller look. It features a low-oil formula that creates exquisitely natural brows by allowing you to draw fine hair-like strokes. And thanks to its super-fine twist-up point, you won’t have to worry about sharpening it.
What’s more, you’ll be pleased to know that it’s packed with skin-nourishing ingredients, namely Vitamin E, squalane , and jojoba . So, rest assured that it will hydrate the skin, irrespective of the skin type. As Kimiko is a sustainable and clean beauty brand, this pencil is free from paraben, sulfate, and phthalate.
It imparts a subtle shine to the brows because of its creamy texture, which not everyone likes.
Easy to use and smudge-proof – this eyebrow pencil by Kimiko glides on easily and seamlessly blends with your natural brow hairs, creating a more fuller and natural look. It comes in three shades (latte, coffee, and black tea) and we were impressed with its lasting power as it perfectly withstands heat and humidity.
6. KOSAS Brow Pop Dual-Action Defining Pencil
Still haven’t found the right eyebrow pencil for your skin tone? Then check out KOSAS Brow Pop Dual-Action Defining Pencil, which comes in ten whopping shades. Whether you want a lighter shade or a darker one, the brand has got you covered with its diverse shade range. And thanks to its dual-sided triangular tip, you can use it to shape and sculpt brows to your liking.
Flaunting a conditioning duo of panthenol provitamin B5  and castor oil , it promotes hair growth and hydrates skin. Along with that, it contains jojoba oil that improves the skin barrier and promotes hair thickness. And since the formula contains nourishing ingredients, it is highly pigmented, which means it will stay put for hours without smudging or transferring.
We’d like to mention that this pencil sports a thick tip, so it gives brows a slightly sloppier look.
This eyebrow pencil from Kosas is excellent for those who have scanty eyebrow hairs and want to define their brows by shaping and sculpting them. Furthermore, it’s resistant to smudge, fade, and transfer, making it perfect for everyday use.
7. Ecobrow Defining Crayon
The retractable and easy-to-use Ecobrow Defining Crayon is perfect for creating natural-looking eyebrows for any occasion you want. Thanks to its unique slanted tip, you can create a more dramatic look or accentuate your natural shape by filling sparse areas. The versatility of this pencil is limitless!
It’s infused with tocopheryl acetate (Vitamin E) , to soften skin and strengthen its protective barrier while fighting free radical damage. Besides, hydrogenated soybean oil , vegetable oil, and copernicia cerifera wax, to name a few, are some ingredients that contribute to the efficacy of the product. That’s not all; it comes in six color options, from golden to chocolate brown shades, which is impressive.
Though it offers excellent coverage, it doesn’t last all day.
If you’re looking for an eyebrow pencil that offers excellent coverage and a matte finish, then this crayon by Ecobrow is perfect for you. We also appreciate that this self-sharpening pencil comes with a spoolie for easy blending.
Some of the common ingredients found in organic eyebrow pencils are as follows:
1. Vitamin E
For over 50 years, Vitamin E has been used in dermatology because of the plethora of benefits it offers. Packed with antioxidant properties, it is used in eyebrow pencils to protect the blend from oxidation while fighting free radical damage caused by exposure to the sun. It also protects skin from premature aging and strengthens its lipid barrier.
2. Candelilla Wax
The next ingredient that we found in most eyebrow pencils is candelilla wax. Of course, it’s used to texturize and harden the formula of the pencil, but it also soothes and softens the skin.
What’s more, it is excellent for dehydrated skin as it locks in moisture and prevents the signs of aging. We’d also like to mention that it’s odorless, non-sticky, and non-toxic, making it safe for all skin types.
3. Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil
As the name suggests, it’s a vegetable oil composed of triglycerides of fatty acids. As it’s an excellent moisturizer and emollient, it prevents loss of hydration, soothes, and softens the skin, which is why it’s commonly found in cosmetic products, including eyebrow pencils.
Are They Worth It?
Absolutely, yes! Brow pencils are totally worth your money because not everyone is blessed with oh-so-perfect eyebrows.
So, when you shape your eyebrows with brow pencils and fill in the sparse areas, they will frame the face and give the illusion of a facelift. What’s more, the versatility of eyebrow pencil is limitless as you can use it for filling in sparse areas, accentuating the natural brows, and sculpting them for a more dramatic look.
And let’s be honest, they are easy on the pockets compared to eyebrow extensions and relatively painless. So, if you ask us, we’d suggest splurging money on eyebrow pencils as they are worth every cent.
Where To Buy?
Have a local makeup store in your alley? If yes, then we suggest buying eyebrow pencils from the store as you can use the testers before splurging money on the products.
Or, if you want to order them from the comfort of your home, then log in to the website of the brand, add the product to the cart, and they’ll be delivered shortly. Alternatively, there are various third-party platforms like The Detox Market, Amazon, and Credo, where you can order eyebrow pencils from multiple brands without paying extra shipping charges.
Here’s why you must consider stacking your vanity with organic eyebrow pencils:
- Free from harmful chemicals
- Offers a lot of control
- Relatively easy on the pockets
- Enhances the makeup look
- Long-lasting and smudge-proof
With that, we’ve reached the end of our guide on the best organic eyebrow pencils for a full and natural look.
Hopefully, you enjoyed reading our guide as much as we enjoyed curating it. But before we sign off, here’s a quick rundown of our favorites from the list.
The PYT Defining Brow Goals Pencil is our top pick because it offers excellent coverage, blends well, and is long-lasting. But if you’re looking for an eyebrow pencil that will accentuate your natural brows, the Ere Perez Almond Eyebrow Pencil is the best bet.
And that’s it for today! Take care, lovelies!